It’s World Cup time and I love following the games. I’m a rare kind though in that most people around here will never watch a game outside of the World Cup, where I will watch one any time I’m given the chance. That’s unfortunately not often as I don’t have cable so I don’t get the special channels that carry the games from the leagues around the world.
In fact, I’d rather watch a good game of footy than our “national sport” hockey.
I was talking with an English acquaintance the other day about the World Cup and she asked me why I thought that soccer was so big everywhere else in the world, but not in Canada and the US. After thinking about it for a minute, there’s one very big point against North America that other soccer leagues don’t have to compete with. Geography.
Most countries that are extremely soccer crazy are in Europe and South America. These countries are small (comparatively.) The US and Canada each comprise of almost 10 million square kilometers each. Yes, there are other large countries in the World Cup. Brazil and Australia come in just after the US with 8.5 and 7.7 million kilometers, respectively.
However, the next largest 2010 World Cup countries? Argentina with about 2.8 million kilometers, Algeria with 2.3 million and Mexico with just short of 2 million.
All of these smaller countries have very tight-knit soccer leagues because it’s easy to go and see a game live. I’m sure in some of these countries you wouldn’t have to drive more than 2 hours to be able to see your local team play 50% of it’s regular season. If I want to see a professional soccer game here in Canada, I have to drive 2 hours just to see a home game, and chances are there aren’t 50% of the regular season games within a 2 hour plane ride.
So what? Hockey, Baseball, Football (American style) and Basketball all manage to do just fine with the same geographical issues, right? Those other sports have one advantage: the action happens in small and predictable locations. This means they easily lend themselves to TV coverage. So if your team is playing far away, that’s ok. It’s beamed into your living room or nearest sports bar and you don’t miss a lot of the action. Hockey and Basketball are played on very small playing fields. Most of a baseball game is going to be on the pitcher and the batter. A majority of plays in football don’t extend more than 20 yards, with most of the action within a 5 yard span. That makes it really easy for the TV camera to zoom in on the action and make sure you get it. In a soccer game, you may need to see the movements of 4 players 40 yards apart to see the whole play. On a field that’s normally around 115 yards long, the cameras have to stay so panned out that the players look mostly like specks. That’s not interesting, especially on a standard definition TV less than about 36 inches. Maybe now with big screen high-definition TVs soccer might pick up in viewers in North America, but you still don’t get to see in the action like with other TV sports.
Basically, a large-scale soccer league system will never work as well as other sports in North America. However, a conglomerate system might. Pockets of 10 to 12 teams in mini-leagues for regular season play, with rival teams close together. The whole continent could probably support 6-8 mini-leagues, who then supply their two best teams to a season-ending 2 or 3 weeks of playoffs until a final champion is determined. Ontario/Quebec, California and Texas could probably all be league areas on their own. Then include a North Eastern (Canadian Maritmes plus North East US), Southern and North Western (Manitoba to BC, North Western and Mid-west US) League and you’ve got solid groupings of teams that would not only create close rivalries, but inter-league support once the playoffs were reached.
Will this ever happen? I doubt it. If a new game would take hold of the populace of North America I would guess it to be something like LaCrosse first. I don’t see soccer being able to go too big with anything more than high school or collage level teams. All my best to the MLS and they’re doing a great job, but they’ll never be the NFL or NHL in this area of the world.
Filed under: Personal by orion549
8 Comments »